D. L. Webster’s Curing Christianity is an honest and provocative examination of some of the unhealthy ways Christianity can be practiced and communicated. Webster argues that Christianity itself does not need to be abandoned, but that Christians need to confront fear, shame, church hurt, unhealthy religious practices, and questionable interpretations of Scripture.
A central theme is the contrast between fear and love. Webster believes Christians can become so focused on judgment, rules, and religious performance that they lose sight of the character of God revealed in Jesus. His discussions of hell, purity culture, sexuality, mental health, and biblical authority are intended to help readers rediscover a healthier faith centered on Jesus and love.
Many of the points Webster covers are ones that I have preached on. I believe that too many Christians get distracted by fears instead of focusing on God. Many times, Scripture tells us to “fear not”. God wants us focused on what He tells us to do instead of living in fear.
From a traditional evangelical perspective, Webster raises some important questions. The church should certainly reject shame-based Christianity, fear as a tool of manipulation, and the misuse of Scripture. His reminder that our Christianity should actually look like Jesus is particularly valuable.
At the same time, I found some of his conclusions more difficult to accept. Love cannot replace the whole counsel of Scripture. God is love, but Scripture also teaches that God is holy and just. We should reject distorted presentations of hell without rejecting what Scripture teaches about judgment. Likewise, Christians can misuse the Bible without diminishing its authority.
Ultimately, Curing Christianity is more valuable as a conversation starter than as a complete theological treatment. Webster asks questions the church should be willing to consider, even when his answers require careful biblical examination.
The cure for unhealthy Christianity is not less Jesus or less Scripture. It is more Jesus and a deeper, more faithful understanding of Scripture.
Recommended for readers interested in church hurt, Christian deconstruction, spiritual health, and examining how faith is communicated and lived out.


